Marvel MaXimum Collection Review (PS5)

It’s a good time when you see retro titles being brought to modern-day consoles. Limited Run Games is one of the developers championing this. Retro games being brought up give more players the chance to experience the classics. And with this new array of games, you get to see some great and not-so-great picks. With the Marvel MaXimum Collection, we get good optimization for some games, but other aspects need extra work.

Some Excelsior titles paired with weaker sidekicks

The main attraction of the MaXimum Collection is the lineup of games. And Limited Run brings some really amazing titles, with some that are still disappointing. To start, the addition of X-Men: The Arcade Game is a massive win here. Being able to access this on consoles is huge, and playing through it was a blast. Furthermore, having Captain America and The Avengers, plus Maximum Carnage, is an addictive bunch to enjoy.

However, the MaXimum Collection has some weaker titles that dampen the experience. That being the Arcade’s Revenge, which features ridiculous game and level designs. It also comes with the Silver Surfer title, which is infamously difficult as a shoot ’em up title. And lastly, Separation Anxiety, which feels like a downgrade when compared to Maximum Carnage. The titles can be off-putting to players, and there are so many stronger choices in my opinion.

For example, we could have had The Punisher, X-Men: Children of the Atom, Clone Wars, or even Wolverine: Adamantium Rage. Some of which have a stronger impact on the retro community than the weaker titles. After playing through them, I felt myself longing for the other titles. This is something that doesn’t usually happen for me when it comes to retro collections.

Sometimes, cheats and settings aren’t villainous

A great feature of this compilation was the addition of cheats and settings for players. When booting up the game of your choice, you can toggle cheats on or off. So if Silver Surfer is grieving you, no longer does the iconic alien get defeated. Instead, you can turn on Infinite Health! It takes the years of being stuck on a level and melts it away. Or if you would rather take damage and keep your lives, there is a cheat for that. Players get the opportunity to make titles easier in this regard, and it allows the collection to be more accessible.

Additionally, some of the titles, like X-Men: The Arcade Game, come with different settings, allowing you to create a gameplay experience of your own choosing. Whether it’s a casual romp or a more hardcore retro adventure, it’s a great addition, along with the cheats that can make the games easier overall and more enjoyable.

While cheats and the settings may be frowned upon, they help players. And with how tricky some of these games were growing up, they are useful. So the developers allowing you to have these is a big plus. And it can help you learn the games to do more challenging runs later on. So if you’re worried about a game being impossible, you can quell those fears.

marvel maximum collection cheats screen

Multiplayer is a depowered experience

The aspect of online multiplayer was a big appeal to me when it was announced. Being able to smash through a game like X-Men with friends was important. But then, I got to dive into it, and it is upsetting. What I found was a laggy mess, where it feels better to avoid rather than experience. In a six-player experience for X-Men, it was skipping everywhere and wouldn’t ease up at all. And as a big attribute for the collection, it’s hard to deal with.

It utilizes Rollback Netcode to ensure that things are smooth and every hit lands well. However, it’s rough right now. While it can be patched with time, it’s still a bummer to see. More so when it comes down to it being the big hit of the entire collection. After some experimentation with the online, it seems to have this consistent problem currently.

While the games thrive in a single-player world, they have multiplayer for a reason. And for some who don’t have retro-loving friends, the online component is the key. Plus, with the inclusion of Captain America and The Avengers, it feels like the game is missing out on allowing multiplayer for that as well. With the netcoding being fixed and multiplayer support for another game, it could really add some more power to the collection.

marvel maximum collection multiplayer screen

Classic Marvel has its retro charm

Retro games have always looked beautiful to me. The pixels and sprites are ingrained in my mind, and this collection is no different. When you boot up any game, you see them as they were back in the day, whether it’s Separation Anxiety or Silver Surfer. Each of the versions is kept true to its respective platform when it comes to visuals. And they look great. They still shine with that retro feel from the good ol’ days.

When it comes to the audio, it’s just as superb. Nothing sounds better than “Welcome to Die.” Or the iconic but terrifying laugh that Carnage gives in the intro of Maximum Carnage. Something that used to frighten even the toughest of players. But the real winner of the games is the music. X-Men or Captain America and the Avengers have classics that are still playing in my head. Hearing them untouched is wonderful and allows them to maintain their charm.

When it comes to retro remasters, giving them upgrades is fine. But the magic of maintaining them close to what they were is important. Both visually and audibly, the collection does well with that. For players looking to dive into some classic retro feels and not a modern age retro, you’re in luck in this regard. And to make things feel like it more, you can even throw on a CRT filter to give it the perspective that many of us got to see back in the day.

venom in maximum carnage marvel maximum collection

The Marvel MaXimum Collection has some lumps and bruises

The Marvel MaXimum Collection presents modern players with a way to play some great retro titles. With physical retro gaming consoles being pricey, it’s a good alternative. More so if you are aiming to have fewer platforms. Plus, the addition of different versions of the game gives you different experiences, such as Genesis, SNES, 8-Bit, or even Arcade. Strong titles like the X-Men: The Arcade Game or Maximum Carnage are great to see.

However, they are joined by weaker titles that give less replayability. And take up space for titles that deserved their time in their spotlight instead. Furthermore, the highlight of online multiplayer in the collection is lackluster. And something that needs fixing. Overall, the collection has some solid foundations to it. But, with the hits it takes, it can be a bit shaky for some players to decide on.

With this being the only way to play some of these titles right now, it’s a solid option. But playing through the titles in single-player is the best way to experience it. Another collection of retro titles is always welcome in the modern age of gaming. But with the hiccups that the Marvel MaXimum Collection brings, it feels like a sidekick rather than a true hero for the classic age of gaming.

Review Code From PR/Dev/Pub:
Yes
Score:
7.0


Contributor
Chris has been a big gaming fan since he was four. From his first game being Streets of Rage to the current titles, it's his favorite thing to do. When he isn't writing about them, he's getting lost in another adventure on one of his consoles.